Where To STAY on Shelter Island, NY — Shelter Island Chamber of Commerce
BELLE CREST INN

BELLE CREST INN

SEVEN ON SHELTER

SEVEN ON SHELTER

AVALON MANOR AT CHASE CREEK

DERING HARBOR INN

DERING HARBOR INN

THE CHEQUIT

THE CHEQUIT

HOUSE ON CHASE CREEK

HOUSE ON CHASE CREEK

THE PRIDWIN

TWO SOUTH FERRY B & B

TWO SOUTH FERRY B & B

THE CANDLELITE INN