5. Shell Beach
(directions)
Shelter Island locals often direct visitors in search of peace and quiet to Shell Beach. This hidden spot, located off a narrow and unmarked dirt road, is known for its shells – hence the name – and serene atmosphere. It's a perfect place for a secluded picnic, kayak excursion, or a day spent exploring the sea's edge for marine life. Remember to respect the beach's tranquility and leave it as clean (or cleaner) than you found it. Please note there are no facilities or lifeguards at this beach. You can learn more about this beach and others, as well as any permits required, on our Shelter Island Beaches page.
